The company has an obligation to negotiate under the RLA. In their dec action complaint, they painted the picture where USAPA wants to negotiate seniority but the trouble is, negotiating away from the Nicolau has already been found by one jury to be a DFR. So to negotiate with USAPA exposes the company to a hybrid DFR from the West. If they don't negotiate, then the company alleges USAPA will take legal action against the company in addition to suffering job actions by the East. This stupid a$$ lawsuit by USAPA coupled with their stupid a$$ safety campaign do nothing but prove that the company has a ripe claim. Way to go morons.
I was being sarcastic.
Cleary's letter is vague and only says they filed the lawsuiit over violations of status quo. No mention of how status quo was violated.
The only violation I am aware of is the change in ACARS block logic, which favored the east pilots and hurt the West pilots, so I doubt usapa brought it up from the bottom of the grievence list to a Federal court docket.
Everybody knows the company's suit is ripe. The problem arises that it so closely mirrors Addington, and was even foretold by Wake and Bybee during Addington, that the scabs think they are going to get a pass because of Addington, which they might in a way, if Silver tells "johnny come lately" they missed their chance.