MCIE base closed due to fleet dropping by over 200 aircraft, capacity not needed. No work outsourced.
AFW base closing as a result of BK. Not rolling over like AMFA did with OAK. OAK was shutdown not under BK 1113c process. No comparison, nice try though.
WN opening ONE line of HC, hundreds of airframes outsourced to AAR, ATS, and Aeroman. All engines and components outsourced. AA would love the AMFA agreement at AA. ONly DWH would be open on the overhaul side running maybe five HC lines at best. All engines and components outsourced. Line would get $42 and hour though! Big win there!
The best contracts in the industry for a select group. Look at the contracts in their totality, not cherry pick the things you like. To get the WN deal you need to ditch close to 6,000 jobs to outsourcing. Of course some will say outsourcing isn't cheaper but if you read the article Aeroman pays less than $15,000 annually for mechanics. You can hire 6 for the price of one AMT in the US. That's hard to beat.