As is often repeated around here, "YOU CAN'T FIX STUPID."
Never trade away your 15% first dollar profit sharing for a small percentage increase in hourly rates. Yet the pilots did just that (traded 2/3 of it for a small raise), and thanks to the "me-too" provisions, so did everyone else.
And then because that didn't show enough stupidity, the TWU then traded away the remaining third (5%) for another small raise.
When your oppressive employer finally offers you real profit sharing (15% first dollar profit sharing), you accept it and then negotiate for higher wages WHILE KEEPING THE PROFIT SHARING. Especially when your employer files Ch 11 to become more efficient and it looks like long-term profits may finally be on the horizon. But no, the TWU brain trust is so effing stupid that they agreed to give it all away. Idiots.