Where's the Birth Certificate?

[777 fixer]

Funny, hes conducted an official investigation along the lines of evidence and discovery, doens't seem to be a chooch.....this could be interesting.

Sure he is. Now I wonder how that has panned out for him? If you hear nothing else from him there's your answer. Maybe someone in Maricopa County should investigate where's he's getting the money and manpower to do this given the budget situation there. Would'nt it be funny if they find he has done no such thing and this is nothing more than him runnning his mouth?

 

[777 fixer]

There has been no decision yet defining 'Natural Born Citizen' only mention from time to time.

Then when why do you keep calling the Minor case the relevant issue then? Seems like you are contradicting yourself.

 

[777 fixer]

Here's an interesting link on the whole issue and guess what, right in the first page the author mentions Minor vs Happersett.

He's a birther

Of course he's a birther. He cherry picks facts, makes claims that are not true or are half truths, ignores other facts and makes himslef look like a complete fool.

 

[tom barry]

Funny, hes conducted an official investigation along the lines of evidence and discovery, doens't seem to be a chooch.....this could be interesting.

Pardon me, but what in HEL* is a "Chooch" ?

 

[SparrowHawk]

Of course he's a birther. He cherry picks facts, makes claims that are not true or are half truths, ignores other facts and makes himslef look like a complete fool.

Kinda like Pelosi's response to the 60 minutes piece?

 

[Dog Wonder]

Pardon me, but what in HEL* is a "Chooch" ?

An idiot. 'Doesn't seem to be a chooch' is giving some one the benefit of a doubt.

 

[delldude]

Then when why do you keep calling the Minor case the relevant issue then? Seems like you are contradicting yourself.

It is the first time I believe that SCOTUS mentioned parents in plural when referring to natural born. When the day comes Minor will be large in the argument and cited, among other case law ,as a courts prior definition.

 

[777 fixer]

It is the first time I believe that SCOTUS mentioned parents in plural when referring to natural born. When the day comes Minor will be large in the argument and cited, among other case law ,as a courts prior definition.

It's funny how you continue to mke such a big deal about the Minor case, yet ignore USA vs Ark.

 

[delldude]

It's funny how you continue to mke such a big deal about the Minor case, yet ignore USA vs Ark.

First, it isn't THE LAW OF THE LAND....its a legal precedent just like the reference to parents in Minor.

Second, USA vs Ark deals with birthright citizenship, not the issue of natural born citizen regarding eligibility for POTUS.


I haven't seen, in the case of USA vs Ark, any links to Minor when the natural born argument comes up, wonder why that is.

USA vs Ark is about citizenship and did not address the subject of what defines natural born, two different issues.

Lets put it this way, I seriously doubt Wong Kim Ark could run for President.

 

[777 fixer]

Dell, listen very carefully. The President is natural born. You fantasizing that he is not does not make it so.

 

[delldude]

Dell, listen very carefully. The President is natural born. You fantasizing that he is not does not make it so.

Without out anything objective to bring to the debate, you change the subject.

I am right and you are wrong.

 

[777 fixer]

Without out anything objective to bring to the debate, you change the subject.

I am right and you are wrong.

Oh really? Then why don't you prove he's not a natural born citizen. Have a feeling I'll be waiting a long time on this one.

 

[delldude]

Oh really? Then why don't you prove he's not a natural born citizen. Have a feeling I'll be waiting a long time on this one.

You never proved Wong was natural born, only was granted citizen status.....LOL

 

[777 fixer]

You never proved Wong was natural born, only was granted citizen status.....LOL

Trying to avoid the question I see.

 

[delldude]

Trying to avoid the question I see.

I would if I could but I haven't been afforded the privilege of practicing before the Supreme Court.