My take, after reading most post on what is fair, I think all carry some merit. I think where Nic award might have missed the boat is when using relative position he should have used true percentages. Now my take on this is not centered at any certain group, so here I go. Lets say he looked at all pilots with equal merit, not some more than others, all have an equal interest and value. You start with the top 10% of both list and merge them, one group would have more pilots than the other due to overall size, so what you do is decide how much larger and go from there. For example, if one group is twice as large you slot 2 to 1. 2 east for example 1 west. When done you move to the next 10% so on and so forth. So when you get to the end, I think what you would find, closer to the bottom guys would be mergered with about the same los. After that, now remember no age 65 yet, you could fence exsisting widebodies and bases for say 5 years. I think if that would have happened, you would still have some upset, but maybe not as much as you have now.