argentomaranello
Member
- Aug 25, 2002
- 57
- 0
BIG]:
The markets are answering the question of whether UAL will file with a resounding YES. (UAL common is trading at the same price U traded at before it filed; UAL listed debt is trading at less than 20 cents on the dollar). The better question is the one you raised as almost an afterthought -- can UAL, once inside Ch.11, gain sufficient savings to obviate further need for the wholesale disposition of its assets being discussed in this string? My point all along (although not articulated with the clarity that I would have liked) has been that UAL will be hobbled even in its efforts at bankruptcy reorganization by its current governance structure and the consequent need to pander to the self-interests of its various union constituancies. As I have observed several times in response to CHIP's point about a clear need to eliminate the ESOP structure at UAL, that can't happen until a Plan of Reorganization is adpoted at the END of UAL's bankruptcy process, AFTER all the critical decisions about labor cost will already have been made. Therefore, in my mind, it is unlikely that UAL will (in this current round of bankruptcy filings) wrest sufficient labor cost concessions from its workforce (either through W-2 cuts or, preferably, via significant headcount reduction) to make its domestic system remotely competitive. The real choice for UAL will be to soldier on in its present form, unable to earn an adequate return on invested capital (if it can earn any return at all!), or to perform radical surgery upon itself and remove that part which is bleeding and can't be fixed -- its domestic route network. UAL's international operation can carry on indefinately, functioning as a private welfare-state for its employees inasmuch as it doesn't (and probably won't) face the relentless low-fare competition from carriers operating on the LUV model; but UAL international, as a standalone, requires assured feed -- which is what the USAir codeshare could provide in spades. Even Glen Tilton will be able to grasp that much!
The markets are answering the question of whether UAL will file with a resounding YES. (UAL common is trading at the same price U traded at before it filed; UAL listed debt is trading at less than 20 cents on the dollar). The better question is the one you raised as almost an afterthought -- can UAL, once inside Ch.11, gain sufficient savings to obviate further need for the wholesale disposition of its assets being discussed in this string? My point all along (although not articulated with the clarity that I would have liked) has been that UAL will be hobbled even in its efforts at bankruptcy reorganization by its current governance structure and the consequent need to pander to the self-interests of its various union constituancies. As I have observed several times in response to CHIP's point about a clear need to eliminate the ESOP structure at UAL, that can't happen until a Plan of Reorganization is adpoted at the END of UAL's bankruptcy process, AFTER all the critical decisions about labor cost will already have been made. Therefore, in my mind, it is unlikely that UAL will (in this current round of bankruptcy filings) wrest sufficient labor cost concessions from its workforce (either through W-2 cuts or, preferably, via significant headcount reduction) to make its domestic system remotely competitive. The real choice for UAL will be to soldier on in its present form, unable to earn an adequate return on invested capital (if it can earn any return at all!), or to perform radical surgery upon itself and remove that part which is bleeding and can't be fixed -- its domestic route network. UAL's international operation can carry on indefinately, functioning as a private welfare-state for its employees inasmuch as it doesn't (and probably won't) face the relentless low-fare competition from carriers operating on the LUV model; but UAL international, as a standalone, requires assured feed -- which is what the USAir codeshare could provide in spades. Even Glen Tilton will be able to grasp that much!