Bob, as it turned out Doug hasn't given the respect that they, and I mean "all" those who have built this Airline into what it is today, they deserve! If he had, he could have come up with a better solution to this whole issue. He could have Grandfathered, no pun intended, all retirees that retired before the merger, both AA, and US, into the old system, and those after into this new one! ------ He chose not to! Now, this thread is a good way to vent, but I don't believe it will change anything! Doug has made up his mind, and I really don't think any of this will change it.