The Bagfather
Senior
700: No one is supposing the company's position is going to change.Do you really think changing unions will change the company's position on negotiations?
Look at UA, NW and WN, nothing changed when they changed unions, in fact if you look at NW, AMFA got their rear ends handed to them on a silver platter and took tremendous concessions and loss of jobs.
The IBEW will not be able to accomplish anything differant than any other union in the airline industry.
The point is that most of us believe that we have a much better chance
with the IBEW, The general view, I believe is that the IAM is a mediocre
or average union but the DL141 is for all of the reason's posted above
over the last year a very poor choice to represent us.
Perhaps UA NW WN and NW made the wrong move. Is that what
your saying? I think we'd have to ask them. Were they sorry
they made the shift? Would the old union have done the same thing.
Whoever was representing TWA who really "lost their rear ends" were they
a bad union?
This move can be supported on a whole variety of ways but the
bottom line for me I have no faith in the IAM. What am I to assume?
That they knew the TA wasn't going to pass and that they have some
grand plan which will suddenly appear and prove them right? I tried
that idea but it gradually got erroded away.
To a certain degree 141`was in a very difficult situation. But so was
142. Why was 141 so willing to give up the COC while 142 wasn't?
I think part of it was 141 couldn't figure out how to be fair to the
west with the east being way senior to them. My feeling is that
could have been solved first negotiating the amendable TWU
contract. But here my lack of knowledge betrays me. What do you
think? I dont think they wanted to risk it but they've ended up
risking their represtation. Like I say they were in a difficult
situation.
141 put out a letter warning us of certain "opportunistic individuals"
who were trying to take advantage of the situation for their own good.
That may be true to some degree but they certainly provided a very
rich opportunity.
I think you or someone else has made the point that a union is
only as strong as its membership. Very true. Take PHX for instance
less than 50% voted with the polls at the airport. At my station
most did not vote. We have, especially in the west, a lot of people
who do not believe their vote counts. This drive is getting them
involved and thinking . If that was the only reason it would be worth
it.
OK now I'll get off the soapbox. Thanks BF
"Don't let your facts get in the way of reason
and good judgement" BF 2007(Nov 7 to be exact)