That is everyone’s gripe about every large bureaucracy in existance! Name me one Airline Union that is not perceived that way. Hell-- name me one multilayered government, business, or origination that is not viewed this way. The very nature of nondisclosure agreements and Government oversight serve to further compound this perception in our industry.
The difference is that people work *for* a corporation. A union works *for* it's people.
NDA'S, the RLA, etc. are all well and good, but you're using those as a rationalization for the keeping the status quo. All of those things are what they are. You can still build a bottom-up structure, and foster engagement despite them.
Guys like Timmy use this reality to further divide the Membership with mistrust that is continually inflamed with rhetoric. The N/D guys are the most transparent we have ever had-- They are light years ahead of past regimes in terms of communication and trust!
I was afraid my posts might be construed as a knock against your NC. They're not. My indictment of the current "system" goes far beyond them, and far beyond DL 141.
...then unionism is the perfect place since all can't be satisfied the same way.
My "mindset" is that America's working class needs to start pushing back. We've been conditioned for far too long that "they can do that, brother," "we did the best we could," and "we'll live to fight another day" are acceptable bargaining positions. We've become complacent, and allowed those we've elected to speak for us to do the same.
As for being satisfied, you're absolutely correct. Some place an emphasis on Scope. Others base rates. And so it goes. That's not a bad thing as long as the entire membership is *engaged.* When that happens, almost nothing is impossible.
yes it may be slow but at least things seem to be progressing along for the better...
IMO, slow can be okay (see ROA's comments about government oversight), as long as people are kept involved and informed.
The ibt left the afl-cio along with the SEIU and started their own alliance, they werent thrown out of the afl.
Yep. Change to Win.
Separate from that-and I know I've said it before- IMO Andy Stern was as detrimental to labor as any boss could've ever been.