PilotAction Merger News for US Airways & American Airlines: October 1, 2013
​
Texas Attorney General Announces Agreement To Support American Airlines, US Airways Merger
Combined Airlines Re-Affirm Commitment to Texas Operations
See Story: http://finance.yahoo.com/news/texas-attorney-general-announces-agreement-190700943.html
Video: Texas AG announces settlement to pull out of American-US Airways antitrust suit
See Story:
http://blogs.star-telegram.com/sky_talk/2013/10/-video-texas-ag-announces-settlement-to-pull-out-of-american-us-airways-antitrust-suit.html
Texas Drops Opposition to AMR-US Airways Merger
Meanwhile, U.S. Judge Says Airline Antitrust Case Should Proceed Despite Government Shutdown
CHICAGO (WSJ.com) - Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott, who joined the U.S. Department of Justice's August lawsuit to block the planned merger of American Airlines parent AMR Corp. and US Airways Group Inc., on Tuesday said he is dropping his opposition to the plan.
At a news conference in an American Admirals Club at Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport, the Republican candidate for Texas governor said he reached an agreement with the two carriers that they would maintain scheduled daily service to 22 airports in the state. In addition, DFW would remain a large hub for the "new American" and the company will keep its headquarters in the Dallas/Fort Worth area, the parties said in a news release.
Mr. Abbott, in a press release, said the settlement with American and US Airways "secures common-sense concessions that are in the best interests" of the state. Of particular concern was the potential for reduced service to several of the state's smallest airports and the possible effect that would have on a large contingent of military personnel who rely on American Eagle regional flights to small airports near their bases, he added.
With this deal agreed, Mr. Abbott said he would withdraw his participation in the Justice Department's lawsuit. Tom Horton, AMR's chief executive, and Doug Parker, his counterpart at US Airways, both thanked the attorney general and said they are grateful for his support.
Still, five other states—Arizona, Florida, Michigan, Pennsylvania and Tennessee—and the District of Columbia remain parties to the Justice Department's complaint. American operates a hub in Miami and US Airways has hub airports in Phoenix and Philadelphia. Both carriers have a big presence at Reagan National Airport, near the District of Columbia in Arlington, Va.
Mr. Abbott, a former judge who is in his second term as Texas' top lawman, is running to succeed Republican Gov. Rick Perry. Mr. Abbott has said in the past that he opposed the merger because he thought the diminished competition would lead to higher prices and reduced service. He has taken the rap for that position from his Republican rival in the gubernatorial race and from a Democratic state senator who is expected to join the run for governor, as well as from other Texas politicians and communities.
AMR employs about 73,000 workers, is based in Fort Worth, and has a major hub at DFW Airport. It is an important employer and taxpayer in the state. If the merger occurred, the combined company would retain the current headquarters and add about 30,000 US Airways employees to the rolls. Of the 100,000 combined employees, about a quarter would be based in Texas.
Last week the Texas Association of Business, an influential lobbying group representing 3,000 employers and 200 local chambers of commerce, said its board voted to support the airline merger and oppose the federal lawsuit attempting to block it. "We realize that there is a political aspect to this issue," Bill Hammond, the group's chief executive, said in a statement. "This vote is strictly about supporting the interests of Texas businesses, which is our core mission."
In stock market trading Tuesday afternoon, US Airways shares were up 3.4% to $19.6 on the New York Stock Exchange. AMR's shares trading on the OTC Bulletin Board were up 7.3% to $4.41.
The Justice Department case is scheduled to go to trial in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., on Nov. 25. Due to the government shutdown on Tuesday, the department asked the judge to stay all proceedings until government spending resumes. Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly on Tuesday ordered the trial to go ahead on schedule. She also set another status hearing for Oct. 30.
The government closed at the end of the day Monday because Congress failed to approve spending legislation to fund government operations.
The Justice Department said that under the shutdown, its employees were generally prohibited from working, even on a voluntary basis, except in limited circumstances such as "emergencies involving the safety of human life or the protection of property."
Department lawyers had said that if the judge denied the postponement request, they would continue to work on the case because her action would "constitute express legal authorization" for them to stay on the job.
The Justice Department argues the deal would harm industry competition and result in higher airfares, higher fees and fewer choices for consumers. The airlines say their merger will allow them to offer more flights to more destinations, reduce costs and offer lower prices and better service.
Justice Department lawyers made a similar postponement request Tuesday in a San Francisco federal court that is holding trial proceedings in the government's challenge to a merger of two Internet technology companies. The judge in that case also denied the request.
Judge Won't delay the antitrust trial of American airlines and US Airways
See Story: http://aviationblog.dallasnews.com/2013/10/judge-wont-delay-the-antitrust-trial-of-american-airlines-and-us-airways.html/
Abbott pulls Texas out of lawsuit to block American Airlines-US Airways merger
See Story: http://www.dallasnews.com/business/airline-industry/20131001-abbott-pulls-texas-out-of-lawsuit-to-block-american-airlines-us-airways-merger.ece
What folks are saying about Texas AG dropping out of antitrust suit against American-US Airways merger
See Story: http://blogs.star-telegram.com/sky_talk/2013/10/what-folks-are-saying-about-texas-ag-dropping-out-of-antitrust-suit-against-american-us-airways-merg.html
Let’s group the huzzahs into one item on the American Airlines-US Airways settlement
See Story: http://aviationblog.dallasnews.com/2013/10/lets-group-the-huzzahs-into-one-item-on-the-american-airlines-us-airways-settlement.html/
The Deal: Merger Enforcers Working During Government Shutdown
See Story: http://business-news.thestreet.com/dallas-morning-news/story/the-deal-merger-enforcers-working-during-government-shutdown/12055515
Greg Abbott’s office files note that it has settled lawsuit with American Airlines and US Airways: October 1, 2013
submitted via ECF
The Honorable Colleen Kollar-Kotelly
United States District Court for the District of Columbia
333 Constitution Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20001
Re: United States, et al. v. US Airways Group, Inc., and AMR Corporation
Case No. 1:13-cv-01236-CKK
Notice of Settlement of the Claims of the State of Texas
Judge Kollar-Kotelly:
The State of Texas wishes to notify the Court that it has entered into a settlement agreement with US Airways Group, Inc. and AMR Corporation. The agreement resolves the claims of the State of Texas, but it does not purport to address the claims of the other plaintiff states or the Department of Justice.
The State of Texas is in the process of meeting and conferring with all parties to the litigation to notify them of the settlement. Once we can assure the court that no party opposes our position, the State of Texas will file its Motion to Voluntarily Dismiss its Claims with Prejudice.
Regards,
/s/
Mark A. Levy
Assistant Attorney General
Office of the Attorney General of Texas
Consumer Protection Division – Antitrust Section
District Court Order to Deny DOJ's Stay: October 1, 2013
"Currently before the Court is Plaintiff the United States of America’s [92] Motion for a Stay of Litigation in Light of Lapse of Appropriations. Plaintiff has requested a stay due to the lapse of appropriations to the Department of Justice, stating that absent an appropriation, Department of Justice attorneys and employees are generally prohibited from working, except in very limited circumstances, including “emergencies involving the safety of human life or the protection of property.” 31 U.S.C. § 1342. Defendants have opposed Plaintiff’s motion for a stay.
"The Court concludes that a stay would be inappropriate here for a number of reasons. This case involves a pending merger agreement between two major airlines, with a deadline for completion of January 18, 2014. The closing of this merger has been delayed by the affirmative actions of Plaintiffs in filing this case and seeking injunctive relief to block the merger. In light of these considerations, and the amount of money at stake in this merger, this case is clearly significant for both sides. Furthermore, the resolution of Defendant American Airline’s pending bankruptcy proceedings hinges on the proceedings in this case. In addition, various amici – particularly employees of the Defendants – have a vested interest in the adjudication of this case without delay. Indeed, because of the need for the prompt resolution of this matter, the Court has set an expedited discovery and trial schedule. A stay at this point would undermine this schedule and delay the necessary speedy disposition of this matter. It is essential that the Department of Justice attorneys continue to litigate this case.
"Accordingly, for the reasons set forth above, it is, this 1st day of October, 2013, hereby ORDERED that Plaintiff the United States of America’s [92] Motion for a Stay of Litigation in Light of Lapse of Appropriationsis DENIED.
"SO ORDERED."
S&P Report (Airline Analyst Jim Corridore): October 1, 2013
The court overseeing the Justice Department (DOJ) suit to block the merger between LCC and AMR has denied the DOJ’s move to delay the Nov. 25 trial date, which we see as a positive for the chances of a settlement of the suit. Also, unconfirmed Bloomberg and other media reports say that Texas has reached a settlement with the carriers and will drop its objection to the suit. We see these two items as significantly increasing the odds the merger will be approved. We remain positive on the potential for it to help increase LCC’s ability to compete with larger rivals.
USAPA Update Regarding DOJ Lawsuit: October 1, 2013
This morning, October 1, the DOJ filed a request to stay, or pause the lawsuit proceedings until such time Congress appropriates funds. In the motion (click here to view), the DOJ acknowledges that American and US Airways object to the motion. The DOJ said if the Judge ordered them to proceed they will consider it an order from her and they will proceed.
USAPA President Gary Hummel and USAPA General Counsel Brian O’Dwyer were in Washington, DC this morning for the Scheduling Conference regarding the DOJ lawsuit. In a hearing prior to the conference, Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly
denied the DOJ’s request to stay the case. The Judge indicated she is aware of the merger expiration deadline of January 18, 2014 and will do her best to render a decision prior to that time. The trial will proceed as planned beginning on November 25, 2013.
On Thursday, October 3, USAPA attorneys, along with attorneys from all of the labor groups at US Airways and American, will attend a meeting with the Company’s Antitrust lawyers. This will be a briefing as well as a strategy session where they will discuss any request for future union involvement opposing the DOJ lawsuit.
Finally, should a settlement be reached with the DOJ, there is a 60-day subsequent public comment period. The Company can, and they have indicated they intend to, proceed with the merger without delay during that 60-day period.
APA INFORMATION HOTLINE: October 1, 2013
This is APA Communications Director Gregg Overman with the APA Information Hotline for Tuesday, Oct. 1.
TEXAS ATTORNEY GENERAL ANNOUNCES MERGER SUPPORT, WITHDRAWS FROM DOJ SUIT:
Texas Attorney General and gubernatorial candidate Greg Abbott announced today that the state is withdrawing from participation in the Justice Department lawsuit opposing the pending American Airlines–US Airways merger. The announcement, detailed in a press release issued by American, occurred during a press conference at the DFW International Airport Admirals Club.
Abbott's change of position is based on an agreement between AMR, US Airways and the state of Texas. Under the terms of the agreement, the new American Airlines will maintain scheduled daily service to more than 20 airports in Texas. In addition, the agreement provides that DFW International Airport will be maintained as a large hub airport for the combined airline and that the new American will maintain its headquarters in the DFW area.
In his own press release, Abbott stated, "The settlement is good for American Airlines' customers, the communities it serves and its employees. Our negotiations confirmed that the airline will preserve competition in the marketplace, maintain important routes in Texas and protect jobs."
APA applauds Abbott's decision. The American Airlines–US Airways merger would be pro-consumer and pro-competition, and we are pleased Abbott now agrees the combination of the two carriers would represent sound public policy.
APA and other unions at American Airlines and US Airways released a joint statement of appreciaion this afternoon regarding Abbott's change of position, emphasizing that the merger "makes sense for competition, customers and our members we represent who want nothing more than to compete aggressively."
U.S. DISTRICT COURT JUDGE INDICATES TRIAL WILL GO FORWARD:
During a short status conference this morning, U.S. District Court Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly considered a Justice Department motion to stay the trial pending resolution of the government shutdown. In an order issued this afternoon, Judge Kollar-Kotelly denied the motion, which means the trial will begin as scheduled Nov. 25.
In the order, Judge Kollar-Kotelly wrote, "The court concludes that a stay would be inappropriate here for a number of reasons. This case involves a pending merger agreement between two airlines, with a deadline for completion of January 18, 2014. The closing of this merger has been delayed by the affirmative actions of plaintiffs in filing this case and seeking injunctive relief to block the merger. In light of these considerations, and the amount of money at stake in this merger, this case is clearly significant for both sides. Furthermore, the resolution of defendant American Airlines' pending bankruptcy proceedings hinges on the proceedings in this case."
The motions to compel that the airlines previously filed as part of the discovery process remain under advisement.
That's it for now. Thanks for checking this hotline.
AA Flight Attendants Applaud Texas State Attorney General's Announcement (APFA President Laura Glading Turns Attention to Remaining States on Antitrust Suit): October 1, 2013
In a press conference this afternoon, Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott announced that he would withdraw his support of the antitrust lawsuit seeking to block the merger of American Airlines and US Airways. Texas is one of seven states and the District of Columbia that joined the US Department of Justice in its eleventh-hour lawsuit against the merger, filed in August. The trial is set to begin on November 25.
“I applaud General Abbott for deciding to do what’s right for his constituents,” said Association of Professional Flight Attendants president Laura Glading. “We have over 3,500 flight attendants living in Texas and I’d venture to say the AG’s office heard from every one of them over the past two months. I’m proud of our efforts. Now on to the other six [states].”
Working in concert with other labor organizations at both carriers, APFA has mounted an aggressive campaign to convince the attorneys general supporting the lawsuit to reverse course. With Greg Abbott backing off, the focus will now be on Pam Bondi (FL), Robert Cooper (TN), Ken Cuccinelli (VA), Tom Horne (AZ), Kathleen Kane (PA), Irvin Nathan (DC), and Bill Schuette (MI).
“The tide is turning,” Glading said. “Flight attendants and our colleagues are getting the facts out there and we’re changing minds. The merger is good for consumers, it’s good for the companies, and it’s good for competition.”
APFA Hotline Update (TX AG Withdraws from Antitrust Suit, Government Shutdown, DOJ Lawsuit Update) #2: October 1, 2013
EXAS AG WITHDRAWS FROM ANTITRUST SUIT
In a press conference at DFW today, Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott announced that he would withdraw from the antitrust suit to block the American-US Airways merger. General Abbott’s decision comes after six weeks of sustained pressure from Flight Attendants and other employees. APFA thanks General Abbott for his thoughtful new stance as well as the many federal, state, and local elected leaders that support the merger. In a statement issued just after the announcement, APFA President Laura Glading said, “The tide is turning. Flight Attendants and our colleagues are getting the facts out there and we’re changing minds.” APFA will continue to apply pressure in other states whose attorneys general remain on the suit, including: Arizona, Florida, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Tennessee, and Virginia.
GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN
Today was day one of the much-anticipated government shutdown. As of today, at least 800,000 government employees are on furlough. Among the personnel that are affected are some working at the FAA, TSA, Department of Labor, NMB, Department of Justice, and federal courts. The shutdown is the result of political brinksmanship in Congress, where House Republicans have tried to attach a measure to defund the Affordable Care Act to legislation to fund the government. APFA has initiated a CapWiz to assist Flight Attendants in contacting their representatives in Congress to demand an end to the shutdown.
Click here to participate.
UPDATE FROM ANTITRUST COURT
APFA is pleased to report that the Court in the DOJ antitrust lawsuit today ruled that the case will proceed on its expedited schedule despite the government shutdown. Early this morning, the DOJ had filed a motion to stay the case because of the lapse in appropriations. This afternoon, however, the Court denied the motion, highlighting that “particularly employees” of both American and US Airways have a “vested interest in the adjudication of this case without delay.”
The Court also held a Status Hearing to address procedural and scheduling matters. The parties agreed that by no later than October 15, 2013, they will submit a report to the Court governing various trial-related dates and procedures. The Court also scheduled another Status Hearing for October 28, 2013. Finally, the Court scheduled a Pre-Trial Conference for November 21, 2013.
AmericanAirlines + US Airways
"MERGE!"
Leslie Mayo
APFA National Communications Coordinator
Unions Representing 70,000 American Airlines and US Airways Employees Applaud Decision by Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott to Support the Combination of the Two Airlines
Charlotte, NC, Euless, TX, Fort Worth, TX, and Washington, DC – September 30, 2013 -- The Association of Flight Attendants-CWA (“AFA&rdquo
😉, the Allied Pilots Association (“APA&rdquo
😉, the Association of Professional Flight Attendants (“APFA&rdquo
😉, the Communications Workers of America (“CWA&rdquo
😉, the International Brotherhood of Teamsters (“IBT&rdquo
😉, the Transport Workers Union (“TWU&rdquo
😉 and the US Airline Pilots Association (“USAPA&rdquo
😉, unions representing 70,000 American Airlines, American Eagle and US Airways employees, including pilots, flight attendants, mechanics, technicians, aircraft dispatchers, call center representatives, and others, today commented on Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott’s decision to support the combination of American Airlines and US Airways and to withdraw his participation in the US Department of Justice’s (“DOJ&rdquo
😉 lawsuit.
The unions issued the following statement:
We appreciate Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott for supporting the combination of American Airlines and US Airways, adding his name to a long list of elected officials in Texas who support the merger. Over the past few weeks our members have shown – and continue to show – unprecedented support for this combination. Our message “Let us compete. Together.” is being heard loud and clear.
This combination will allow our members to compete on a fair basis in the airline industry and to better serve customers with a stronger airline that will fly more people to more places. Moreover, this combination enhances job security for employees of both airlines because they will be allowed to compete fairly with other merged carriers in the industry.
Attorney General Abbott clearly recognizes the benefits this transaction will bring to Texas. The Dallas-Fort Worth hub will continue to be a key hub of the new American and travelers coming in and out of Texas will benefit from greater connectivity and enhanced service. The combined networks will employ nearly 25,000 people throughout the state of Texas, supporting economic growth in all of its communities.
This combination makes sense for competition, customers, and our members we represent who want nothing more than to compete aggressively. We will continue to make our voices heard.