Ah perhaps there is a way to appease me,,,, Weez notice I said "me"Your assumption is incorrect that NYC (and MIA) do not have advocates in the negotiations to make sure they're voices are heard.
The article involving rotations in NYC has already been TA'd and after full JCBA ratification those affected members will be given a separate vote to determine whether or not they want to continue with the current system on the LAA side.
For clarity on the subject the rotations started in the early 80's out of JFK when management was given the ability to rotate and the Local there at the time fought back that their members should be able to enjoy the benefit also. At the time to hold steady weekends in JFK one needed 24 years with the company.
After it was gained by the Local for JFK it then rolled over as a benefit to LGA members as well.
For Al and his member advocates he will have the chance to vote against the rotations and even if he fails there will be continuing discussions on how and when it will be implemented for his members.