You are good at quote mining. Never did i say it was spectacular. What i said was that it increased scope, and by alot, since it incorporated scope for all stations at another airline that was even 70% larger than lus. The latest sidebars between company, twu and iam would have our group at 15 flights but a bar on new stations. Our negotiation committee isnt even aware of this yet.
The no layoff doesnt prevent layoffs. What it does is offer a right to full time. Doesnt replace scope because scope is the true job protector. That said, at united, you need 17 years to be protected, never mind half of res is contracted out overseas and only 28 stations are under scope.
Complain all day about the cwa but when you open up your eyes and use your own station as witness, you would conclude that the cwa did alot better than the iam since mia has NO united employees.