The argument here is somewhat silly. Whether it's an abuse of sick time, or whether it creates a loss of revenue are irrelevant. What IS clear is that many employees are unhappy with the way their executive level is playing with their income, and their lives. There are many legal avenues that employees can use to get that point across. When those avenues are met with roadblocks, then oftentimes employees, either individually or collectively, must send a message that an employer DOES hear.
When you participate in a "sick out" organized or otherwise, it can easily and quite noticeably affect an employer's revenue. When the employer is a publicly traded company, the signal is received by even more. As an investor, I know what unhappy employees can do to a company's bottom line, affecting what a company I may be invested in is able to pay out to stockholders in dividends. This is one reason many stockholders keep an eye on employee relations within the companies they may have investments in. Its also what prompts many investors to contact company executives to express that displeasure. You have to keep one thing in mind - a board of directors, and therefore the executive level, serve at the pleasure of the stockholders. You piss off enough stockholders and your executive perk-filled job can be yanked out from under you and you can handily be handed your hat in the blink of an eye. Even if you don't piss off enough stockholders to affect change in a board or executive collection, large numbers of unhappy stockholders expressing their displeasure with their vote sends a clear message to other potential investors.
So many people who had huge blocks of AMR stock when the company's stock feel straight into the toilet, held their breath while the stock slowly recovered. Once it reached a level where the losses weren't as bad as they would have been at a buck and a quarter, they bailed out and dumped their stock. Thirteen bucks wasn't twenty-seven, but it was certainly a helluva lot better than a dollar twenty-five. When you look at where AMR was a mere five years ago when their stock was trading at $120.00 to today where it's struggling to stay above 12 dollars, you quickly realize that the economy can't be to blame for all of AMR's frowns. (its also fun to go back and look at the stock's value, and how it changes from republican administrations, to democrat, then back to republican - it's like a roller coaster in stock values - but that's another story).
To sum it up, while I realize that a sick out of any size can inconvenience the airline's passengers (no more than their own cancellations and misconnects probably) it's a clear signal to those who are paying attention that the work force is not happy about the way they are being treated by the company renting their bodies. Add that to the upcoming changes in occupational seniority (which is going to throw thousands of long time employees in line for layoffs before their co-workers who may have as little as three years with the company), and the doubling of the co-payments for prescription drugs for the second year in a row and other sizeable changes to employee benefits packages, some employees actually begin to wonder if they can afford to work FOR American Airlines anymore.
While I don't like to be inconvenienced at any airport, I fully support any group of employees who are attempting to send a signal to their employer who otherwise can't hear their because their ears are stuffed with million dollar perk filled slush funds.
Be it flight attendants, fleet service, pilots, agents, maintenance, ramp, whatever, as a group if you're not satisfied with the treatment you receive from your executives, I say go for it, do what it takes to get your employer's attention. If they still won't listen, send a louder signal.
Employees who won't speak up for themselves, or decide to play the mouse are sending a signal to employers that they are complacent, and will take whatever abuse is heaped on them, prompting employers to heap more and more on them.
AMR would like nothing more than to have every single employee reduced to minimum wage, no overtime, no healthcare and no job security. That is the only thing that will make your executive level happy.