And OJ didn't do it! The bigger question when Bybee will see the error of his ways! Hasn't the DJ been remanded to the group that said something about a "final product"What's a Bush Torture Team? Apparently Bybee's actions don't constitute High Crimes and Misdemeanors by any standard since he is still actively serving as a member of the Ninth Circuit just as you noted. If he's on the bench when the DJ or any other appeal in the SLI dispute reaches the Ninth then I suspect his opinion (which has been against USAPA's position) will go on the judicial record just like any of his colleagues. If Tashima or Graber see their errors in the precious ruling based on the the fact there is still an active dispute they didn't relieve, well then his vote will suddenly become a majority and a dissenting one.