No, actually I agree with your statement above (the one in bold).
However, after many years of careful review of many publications and web sites on the issues of aircraft mechanics and MRO's in this country, I truly believe that organizing the airline mechanics into a single craft union will do no good unless the MRO's are organized also.
After the financial hit in 2001, MRO usage boomed as the airlines found savings in the FAR 145 repair stations. The airline employed mechanics ranks shrunk and the MRO's began hiring (every airline except AA). This was the time that all unions, IBT IAM included should have been organizing these groups. They failed too. I am not arguing that. My question, (and I directed this to the National Director years ago) why didn't AMFA, the mechanics craft union, take advantage of the situation then?
As a Craft Union, this should have been a no brainier. Especially then, when AMFA represented close to 20,000 mechanics. It could have been easy to begin organizing drives at the MRO's.
I am not arguing that ALL the Unions failed. But only one calls themselves a Craft Union.
You keep going back to the MRO's...Yes I think they should have gone after the MRO's but they had a hard enough time fighting off the efforts and deep pockets of the industrial unions and the airlines who wanted AMFA gone since they were not the "LAPDOGS" they current unions out there seem to be. Why I became a mechanic I will never know..If I had known when I got my A@P that the unions and the NMB were working so hard to keep mechanics down I would have NEVER gone into this and to this day I dissuade young ones from going into this field...The IAm TWu and the IBt should hang there F'kng heads in shame. They have NEVER represented the AMT or respected the A@P I refer to the IAm famous quote "my drivers license is the same as your A@P" and the also famous " a loaf of bread costs the same for everybody" bullshit. If I had been smart I would have got my ADX dispatch license 20+ yrs ago and went there instead of getting my ADX now at almost 50. I would have had my own union representing only US..Would have only invested 6 weeks and 200 hrs instead of 2 yrs and 2000 hrs to make better money, more respect, never having to work in the weather or on shitters and have jumpseat priviledges on not only my carrier but others while the AMT is left at the gate watching the plane leave the gate cuz he can't get on....Tell me why anyone should be a mechanic and why your crappy unions representing those AMT's should invest any time and money pursuing this trade? Better off staying on the F'kn ramp.