Yes better with Jim Little, the 3 unions voted in those contracts to prevent a BK. If you remember the other airlines went BK and gutted the contracts and laid off thousands and outsourced their OH, just like AA is doing now. In 2003 who would have guessed that the Iraq war would have dragged on until 2011, that the war in Afghanistan wouldn't be truly addressed until 2009, the spike in fuel 2007 and the financial collapse in 2008, which lead to the worst recession sense the great depression. Which are all hits on the economy which means tough times for the travel industry.
On top of that you had a lot of poor management decisions like giving themselves bonus's when AA is losing money. Yes it's part of their compensation package, but they should use different nomenclature other then BONUS, bonus implies they did something exceptional, which does not equate to running the airline into BK. All that created a toxic relationship with the 3 unions.
I think we are better off with Little, rather then with the hard line restore and more crowd who do not realize this is not 2001 and we don't have that kind of leverage. If we keep following that crowd we're mostly likely going to lose more. How is it working out for OH with the I'm not working weekend coalition.
The only good thing coming from this is that AA will have no excuse not to pay us SWA wages after getting everything they want during BK. That will be the TWU's next challenge unless some other union comes in.