Here you go, from the bankruptcy court documents as the APA was fighting the abrogation of their CBA.
"APA’s proffered (and inadmissible) evidence shows that American made offers to each of its unions to reduce the 20% labor cost reduction figure sought in litigation to a smaller figure (17%) as an inducement to settle and in return for long term stability, certainty, and labor peace. Everyone but the pilots accepted. APA now claims that it is entitled in litigation to the quid without surrendering the quo — to use the 17% figure as the benchmark figure for a new “necessity” inquiry — a figure inextricably linked in American’s compromise offers to the labor stability and certainty that come from a long-term deal before an exit from Chapter 11 — without agreeing to a thing. Allowing APA to accomplish this feint would punish the other unions for making the sacrifices necessary to get the lowered figure..."
So, in Court, LAA admits all unions with contracts received the 17%, the APA was fighting to get the 17% while the airline continue to hold them to the 20% until, like the other unions, they agreed to a BK CBA.
This submission was in August 2012 and the APA didn't get a contract until December 2012. As a point of reference the TWU contracts had dates of September 12, 2012
Read it yourself, PDF
I see you’re still playing that tune all these years later. The only difference between the 20% ask and the 17% supposed better deal is the international gave away 2/3rds of our new profit sharing plan. I hammered the international on what changed between the 20% ask and the 17% acceptance and no answer. It was a scam. The pilots got a snap back built into the deal that no one told us about. When it came out in the paper they were getting it we ask about the me-too provision that the twu used to get the contract ratified. The union said oh that doesn’t apply anymore. That was the bait the cocksuckers used to get everyone to vote yes on the deal. “Vote yes brother and if the pilots get a better deal you will get it to”
Ya fukn right!!!