This merger is about consolidation, and pricing power. The combined AA/US would have improved pricing power to the Caribbean for example. Consolidation would also produce better yields in the Florida north/south market.
It takes me to long to explain my view point on past "government over site" of this industry. But from 1980-2000, the bottom line is the industry was forced to compete at ridiculous levels, until labor was beaten into the ground in the name of cheap tickets. That is now complete and the Government has started allowing long over due consolidation.
In the end there will be fewer planes, fewer empty seats and higher airfares.
There still seems to be the idea that AA would come out on top. Really? Why in the world would US want AA as a whole entity? AArrogance, labor problems, poor industry customer service perception (not that I agree) and still the mess of the prior merger. In a bk situation (unless it is a pre-pack) all bets are off. If an acquisition is going to happen it has been planned for a long time (like the TWA acquisiton). The TWA deal was carefully planned so that ALL the financial warts were properly placed. From the outside it is deja vu....