GorgeousGeorge
Senior
- Apr 29, 2008
- 326
- 357
You aren't alone in your thinking but I and many others out west are willing to bet that you're wrong. Just as the east is willing to throw themselves on their swords over DOH, so are we on the west to defend the expensive and time consuming arbitrator's decision. Each side believes it is right. The courts will decide.
They will in about 10 years as that is the pace of the courts in such cases. In the unlikely event the court decides in your favor, it is highly unlikely the courts remedy will change the list that has been functioning the preceding decade. Nicalou will not be an issue as it exists only as a bargaining position of a previous collective bargaining agent. You will be hanging your hat on the fairness of DOH integration with nothing to compare it to except the respective East and West lists as they are all that exist. A bargaining position does not constitute a list.
There is a pending grievance between union and company over the active mainline E170 pilots. If they win and clearly there was no other airline they were working for, 2+ years of longevity will be restored to hundreds of East pilots and a win would also prejudice the DFR suit against ALPA.
The E170 DFR case against ALPA of which Nicalou and the seniority arbitration is a part of will conclude years before the DFR suit you contemplate.
Your time and efforts would have been better spent working on conditions and restrictions within the union and a new contract but I fear only ten years of hindsight is going to show you that.