Someone sent me a PM and asked me to respond to the topic, as a retired US "east' employee. I retired as an F/S agent. I am over 60, not yet 65 yrs old.
I had:
1. Piedmont Pension plan, which was frozen by US and 401k plan started. This plan was turned over to PBGC and I now receive a monthly check from PBGC, luckly in the same amount that it was going to be thru the original Piedmont plan (which indicates that it is not a high amount, as no penalties were applied by the PBGC)
2. US basically froze my 401k plan. That money (the amount I had contributed and the amount US matched), so I have been told, is not available to US as the plan is managed by private company. Not having a 401k plan saves US money by not matching or having to administer the plan(the real question is can you believe what you are told)
3. I became a part of the IAM plan and was in it 2 yrs before retiring. I receive a check from them each month for approx $120. (I think the $ amount in a previous post is about correct for both full time and part time.... you can do the math for yourself)
.
I was asked which I would perfer. My choice would be 401k, because the employee decides where to invest his/her money...especially if there is any company match. (you can make $ or lose $....monitor quarterly reports you receive and change to something else if your stock/etc is habitually losing $). BUT for a 401k to produce any $ at all....THE EMPLOYEE MUST CONTRIBUTE TO IT. If you don't, you have no retirement. At low wages, I fear that people have no extra cash they think they can put aside for the future, as it takes all you make to get ends to met now. If memory serves me corr, participation in IAM plan is not optional...nor do you have a choice how the money is invested. However; at least with it not being an optional contribution, employees are forced to set aside some money that hopefully will be there for the employee at retirement. I have no idea what happens if IAM is booted out and you are still an active employee, nor do I know what happens if the union itself should cease to exist.