What IS simple is the fact that the APFA concessions were terribly undervalued at the time of the RPA. I (and several others) volunteered to price out the CBA based on the value at the time of implementation. At that time I was on furlough, not planning to retire, and had time on my hands and 30 years of union experience. I believe that we could have presented compelling documentation that the concessions were actually close to 650,000,000 instead of the "requested" 340,000,000. In addition, there was never any credit given for the salary and benefits savings for the 6000+ furloughs. From the beginning there has been a tongue in cheek or "wink wink" attempt at addressing the recall issues. The furloughed are being held hostage to the many litigation issues still pending. I would hazard a guess that some movement MIGHT occur IF the lawsuits were dropped. AAs ability to shift to AE without penalties (or credit to AAs unions) is the other reason we won't see recalls. Ethics and integrity are the things that make me go hummmmmm.