Sure there is no right or wrong way. But there is a smart and dumb way. If I recall, we were presented with a 7 year bump with fences. Didn't fly. Then a 4 year bumb, no fences. Vote passed. That was incredible to see the SWA majority vote this in. Teamsters easily out maneuvered amfa. Then SWA unloaded the 717's with a contract that only allows a minimum of 2.75 mechs per aircraft. Overmanned is what you have now. AirTran mechs only lost 4 years. Lucky to have a job. They all received huge pay raises, more days off, etc,etc... Teamsters did a great job with the situation they were dealt. What did the amfa mechs get? Nothing, with most losing seniority. Unionism 101- never vote yourself out of seniority. Let somebody else stick the fork in your neck..