I agree. East is $247 million and West is $68 million.
That should have been the appropriate way to handle this with your boy providing what % of the $68 million would be the West f/as and provide the appropriate language for their profit sharing until a negotiated transition agreement is achieved.
Perhaps you are correct, but it doesn't take to much imagination to envision the following scenario:
1. Tempe makes it well known that they offered profit sharing for the West f/a's, but the East MEC rejected the idea.
2. Tempe then offers the West f/a's profit sharing equivalent to the total amount that would have been paid anyway.
3. Tempe generates good will toward the company while driving an iron wedge between East and West AFA.
Perhaps I'm just being cynical, but I can understand why East AFA made the call they did.