I personally never believed that was a promise that could be kept.
probably if that individual happens to be a pilot and the furlough involves "pilots"
it may be very inconvenient having to re-locate to another city or transfer to another base..(if a base closed..ext as what has happened in the past for Flight Attendants when they closed the ORD base) but you know in this industry....base closures, downsizing..happens. they need to carefully take many other people into consideration...employee's families too.
fortunately for Flight Attendant ORD is re-opening for a limited time, but it is opening and I hope that will mean 'long term' for those who want to be back at their former base.
that is one reason why I strongly feel it is imperative, the employee has a say in how these situations are handled, in that one regard, having something..(anything) in writing may be something to consider.
ultimately however, it is completely understandable how some people may view that situation..as a layoff (even if a job is offered somewhere else) ..as it is very difficult for parents to take their children out of schools, selling a home relocating to a different city, especially in this economy...(there may be a situation where someone just cannot re-locate at all) so, they need to try and keep their most loyal and dedicated work force at their stations(especially those on the ground) if possible, while remembering a job is more than just a title or position it also can affect many other lives.
we dont need any more unnecessary stress at this time.. while attempting to focus being the worlds premier airline.. if the bottom line is simply trying to save a buck.