As in your comparo above, apples to apples per say, legacies to legacies, and LCC's to LCC's, if you ran the numbers this way SWA becomes top LCC as AA is with legacies. What was surprising was seeing UAL beating out Delta for 2nd place. Were you not shocked by this? I know I was. Even the investors were taken off guard by it. I know you LUV your Delta, as you should, but it was a shocker watching Delta going from #1 for earnings to #3 at the flip of a switch, I was not expecting that. It really does look like UAL is starting to get thing right and better, just wasn't expecting this quick and passing up Delta so quickly. If UAL could get all the contracts into one then they would even save more, however, AA still needs to do the same, but Delta (I believe) is already in single contracts. Here's the article where I read all this and was shocked where Delta ended up:WorldTraveler said:doesn't hurt me at all to post whatever WN achieved. I can live with facts.
I simply didn't know WN's operating margin. Thanks for posting it. and yes WN's operating margin was about a 1/2% higher than DL's and the largest of the big 4. congrats.
I did notice that DL's ROIC was above WN's.... saw that comparison somewhere. Perhaps you can find the numbers and post them for me.
And again, I have repeatedly said that there was every expectation that AAL would post a higher profit in pure dollars because AAL is a larger company.
By the same token, DL is a larger company than WN. I guess Í now have your permission to say that DL posts a larger profit than WN since DL is a larger company.
As Kev very aptly said a few days ago, it is absolutely great that we are now discussing who has the highest margin when practically the entire industry is above 10% operating margins.
That is just incredible.
The employees do need a few bones thrown to them.... I suspect in the case of DL, UA, and WN that will come largely via profit sharing.
Those who remember the last big profit cycle of the airline industry in the late 1990s (when DL had the highest profit margin of any airline in the US and UA recorded the highest total profit) will remember that unions demanded huge pay raises. The battle cry of UA's pilots was something to the effect of squeezing the goose that lays the golden egg.
A few short years later, UA was in BK and the "pattern bargaining" that ensued resulted in billions of dollars in lower wages.
I don't think airline mgmt. teams forget what happened and certainly don't have any desire to do anything like it again.
Labor can and should make incremental gains - not unlike the 2-3% increases that wnmech noted but with the biggest part of compensation increases coming via "at risk" compensation such as profit sharing.
We, of course, will see how it all plays out but I expect that labor will make small but steady gains instead of huge increases.
The fundamentals of the industry are strong which should allow for profitability on a sustained basis and perhaps at worse breakeven should a major downturn occur.
Profits at US airlines top $4 billion in second quarter