When the industry is looked at as a whole, the continental rampers are among the highest paid, certainly above the avg union wage, and don't pay union dues. WN is the highest next is AA, then Continental at about $19.45. If you add union dues to a wage fee then AA rampers are similar to the $19.45 of the continental rampers.
AA is now looking at going back to its rampers and other employees to get more. And the NW rampers just got a new tentative that includes yet another 15% or 16% pay cut.
Looking at the state of the industry, job protection is always based on the growth of your particular company, whether union or not. And even though Delta followed the IAM's lead at US AIRWAYS and contracted out all non-hub/non-big stations, the unions have led the way of contracting out more work than the non-union airlines.
regards,