At least the APFA does what the IAM at TWA didn't do....PROTECT IT'S MEMBERS!!
Remember our "iron clad" SCOPE clause is the one yours was patterned after...anything can be broken. It was a carefully orchestrated deal of which bk and the abrogation of our contract was "the deal", not part of it, "the deal". TWA COULD have been kept separate, work rules, pay, perhaps flying all charter flights but the APFA fought for single carrier status. Why? Dues money. 4200 extra monthly dues was just too big of a temptation. By that act of petitioning the NLRB, we became members, will equal rights of protection. It is not about super seniority, it is about having been in the same position as you, with the same ratio of acquired and the knowledge that it just wasn't that big of a deal. We had cross utilization so our international flying was even more diluted, and it just wasn't a big deal. I was still able to hold the same flights. Occasionally, on different days, but that was rare. You don't know until you've been there, done that... And, you pay is now what ours was, but without the compensating work rules. Truly industry leading.
Industry leading pay, not work rules. Cost me several thousand a year and I had to fly more days. AND I lost a 14% 401K contribution. AND I had to pay for medical insurance. I'm in a little different position as I was on an OVL when the mass furlough occurred so the furlough (for me) came at a good time. I had spent so much time and energy fighting for FMLA that knowing I was going to be home was a relief.
Once again, it doesn't matter. Those wishing to return are coming back, having a ball, working the system, and doing quite well thank you. Time to think forward. The job has changed but for many, it is still in the blood, and no matter how different, it still beats working for a living..lol Remember, many of our furloughed, even with advanced degrees, still went into new professions, or back into old professions, as new hires with new hire salary and benefits packages.
Disclaimer: This us vs you was for the sake of answering the post...It is all a moot issue because you are now a "we"...