wings396 said:
The Shuttle is not worth what it once was. Too many Airlines with way to much frequency in those markets.
It's not even so much the competition from other airlines on the traditional Shuttle routes. Acela has stolen a bunch of traffic from the Shuttles simply because the plane doesn't save much time versus the train anymore, once you add in the time needed to get to/from the airport and clear security. And the train offers power outlets for laptop users and the ability to use your cell phone, while being considerably less expensive.
I'd add that Delta has taken the lead in market share in both NYC-BOS and NYC-WAS (this includes both Shuttles from LGA, AA Eagle from LGA, and CO from EWR) with about 45% share in each market. So the position of the US Shuttle as being the weaker operation in market share does little to enhance its value as a business (not that it is even a separate business anymore).
What value the Shuttle might offer lies mainly in its LGA & DCA slots along with terminal facilities at DCA, LGA, and BOS. Actually, I'd argue that the BOS terminal leases aren't worth anywhere near what they were four years ago, given that the opening of Delta's Terminal A is going to free up about a dozen gates in Terminal C. Any airline willing to wait about six months will probably be able to pick up a few gates once Delta moves. The value of the LGA sublease is in question as well if CO (from whom US subleases the terminal) has the right of first refusal or can block US from subleasing to another party. The LGA slots are useless unless you have somewhere to park the planes; jetBlue had to delay LGA service for months until it could find a gate to use. DCA, of course, is the real gem, but it remains to be seen how much Independence Air is going to trash DCA yields with its IAD operation. The A319's and A320's only fit in at NWA among the majors due to the CFM engines, and few U.S. airlines will be interested in 737-300's that average about 17.5 years in age.
As others have said, there's almost no value in selling the Europe/Caribbean routes, due to lack of any sort of exclusive route authority AND the lack of viability of the routes without the hubs to back them up. You can't fill most of the CLT-Caribbean flights without the domestic feed of the hub.
At this point, none of the network majors has the cash to spend on a large purchase of UAIR assets. I suspect that most of them are waiting, like vultures, for a potential fire sale. And since the LCC's are the only carriers with the cash to fund asset purchases, that makes asset sales even more unattractive, since US would only be exposed that much more to low-cost competition.