Airbus 'Guessed Wrong' On A350, McArtor Says
By James Ott and Martial Tardy
05/23/2006 10:23:25 AM
Airbus North America Chairman Allan McArtor said the European manufacturer "guessed wrong" in the initial design of the A350 and that by summer it will develop an aircraft that will be more competitive and even dominant against Boeing's 787.
Summer also appears to be the timeframe for French, British, German and Spanish governments to decide if they plan to resume support for the A350 development program, said French Transport Minister Dominique Perben in a May 22 interview with French daily Le Figaro. "We will make a common decision before the opening of the air show in Farnborough," Perben said.
In the meantime, Perben and his colleagues will be informed about the intentions of European Aeronautic Defence and Space Company (EADS) on the future of the A350. "We believe in this project, and we have no intention to continue wasting time," Perben said. European governments suspended launch aid for the A350 program last year as a token of good will to settle their dispute with the United States on state aid to the aircraft industry, which is now pending at the World Trade Organization.
McArtor, meanwhile, said in an interview Monday that Airbus thought the A350 would be successful if it was "put on steroids" and powered by the GEnx engine. But "customers said we want something a little bit different than that, [and] be more aggressive with your innovation."
The former FAA administrator said Airbus is obliged to develop and innovate with each aircraft. He said new design elements will be known in a few months, but he wouldn't comment on development costs. He mused that manufacturers should not "fall in love with legacy programs."
McArtor's assessments follow comments by Airbus CEO Gustav Humbert that a decision on relaunch of the A350 has not been made (DAILY, May 18). At that time, Humbert also said some comments made by his colleagues in the French press regarding the A350 were "not helpful." He made it clear that relaunching the plane would only happen if it increases market ability and improves market acceptance.
Previously, industry sources have said that Airbus management is divided on an A350 revamp, but that supporters of an estimated $3 billion investment are gaining strength (DAILY, May 10).
Airbus North America CEO Barry Eccleston and McArtor joined GE-Aviation President and CEO Scott Donnelly, at the Evendale, Ohio, plant to observe the 35th year of the GE-Airbus partnership that began with the CF6 engine powering the A300. Donnelly said the partnership has meant $30 billion revenues for GE, which has provided, along with SNECMA, 7,300 CFM and GE engines to the airframe maker.