1. Normal wear and tear to a suitcase happens. The suitcase is suppose to protect the contents. You are lucky to have gotten a credit voucher unless there was obvious abuse (large gaping slash where is was dragged underneath a bag cart or caught in the baggage conveyor)
2. Weather and Air traffic contol delays are never covered by the airline. Yes, they should have offered you a list of hotels that had distressed passenger rates but did you go up to the counter pounding your fist, complaining loudly and demanding things or did you nicely ask the agent for obtaining a list of hotels?
3. Pay for your car?? You are the one that opted to change your destination city.
This could have happened on any airline. Refuse to fly again on airine XX everytime something like this happens and you will be booking greyhound on their $199 roundtrip cross country special. (FYI- Greyhound won't give you anything for lost or damaged bags, won't hold a bus for late connecting passengers and certianly won't pay for your car rental if you get off at a different city)
My best advice to you- buy travel insurance. A cheap policy (say $40-$50 for two travelers) would have:
1. Reimbused you for the cost of buying a new suitcase.
2. Reimbursed you for any out of pocket expense for any delays incurred (meals, hotels)
3. Reimbursed you if you chose to purchase another ticket on another carrier to get you to TUS. (Jetblue/Southwest won't protect you on another carrier)
4. Reimbursed you for your car rental
As for the lip you got from the SYR agent- these people are barely making above minimum wage- again were you nice or irrate? Don't expect airlines employees to put up with alot of verbal abuse/venting. They can quit and go flip hamburgers for the same amount of $$ and not put up with people with their panties in a bunch. This is what the airline industry has come down to. In order to offer the internet $59 roundtrip airfare from JFK-LAX the airline has to pay their employees squat.
Memo to travel agent:
Don't make assumptions about someone's demeanor when you do not know what you are talking about. Was I upset? Yes, I was. But I conducted myself in a completely professional and gentlemanly manner throughout. You have no business insinuating otherwise.
As to your assertion that I "opted to change" my destination city, again, you need first to know what you are talking about. Had I not flown to PHX instead of TUS, I would have had to wait at least another 12 hours. Had I waited for flight 105, the day's only flight from JFK to TUS (when in fact it operates), I would have run the risk of a cancellation and a wait of at least another 24 hours beyond that. Bear in mind that Flight 105 had been canceled at least five times in the two month period preceding my experience. I would submit to you that I really had no alternative but to change my destination city. (I even had one JetBlue representative suggest I fly to another city near TUS, such as Houston!!! That shows the geographical ignorance for which provincial NYers are so notorious.)
As far as hotels in the JFK area, a couple of hotels in the area were mentioned to me. However, the agent at the service (?) desk acted as though I was crazy when I told her gate personnel in SYR had mentioned distressed pax rates. She indicated she had never heard of such a thing.
Perhaps I should consider travel insurance in the future. But you know what? In travels on Southwest, American, and even Northwest and US Air, I have never even come close to needing it. I guess I let JetBlue's undeservedly high customer satisfaction ratings lull me into a sense of false security.
And finally, I am aware of the guff airline personnel often take from the public. With that in mind, I strive even harder to be polite and courteous when I have to speak with them concerning matters I know are beyond their control. That said, nobody forces them to work for an airline. As I believe Harry Truman once said, "If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen."
I have sworn off JetBlue koolaid for once and for all.