I was actually excited about a potential improvement over Workbrain, and so I asked about the AA system... what a disaster! In PHX with over 800 fleet service agents I could imagine everyone saying, "Oh, I thought you said I could have that day" or "Oh, I didn't know it was a different day" or "Someone said you were dropping that day" or "Your trading partner said it was okay," etc. and people are showing-up for work when people unknowingly picked up the day??? If I dropped a shift, then I want it as an electronic "handshake"... I sent it and someone picked it up and no reversing it unless I agreed!
I assume you have actually used the AA shift trading process? It is a less-than-obvious link to another less-than-obvious link leading to a new page near the bottom for a drop down menu, then a couple of slow moving screens (which prompts the user to do something, but in reality don't do anything), and finally to where one may review one's schedule or conduct a trade. Then the "calendar" is just a list of dates without days and even though it might claim one is "OFF", upon further review, you might see a shift listed directly below, and without any demarcation between the dates. After seeing that hot mess, I'll take Workbrain with a few of its quirky bugs and links in unrelated pages... at least, it is fast, the bulletin board is easy to use, and the calendar is actually a calendar which one can quickly understand!
And oh? If I want to review my clock-in and clock-out, along with my hours, it is a matter of clicking on the date on the Workbrain calendar, and a window opens to list all the information, instead of having to go back through to the introduction screen and open a different program to a separate time keeping system.
When I have mentioned to other PHX agents about the AA system, the first thing I hear, "I hope we keep Workbrain."