What's new

The idiotic decision thread

ableoneable

Veteran
Joined
May 6, 2007
Messages
711
Reaction score
0
This thread is provided for you, the employee, or you the customer, to provide a narrative of any management decision or practice that both inconvenienced passengers and cost the company revenue.

I will go first.

Let me preface this with the fact that I did not find out about the whole chain of events here until it was too late for me to make the phone calls necessary to fix this problem. In addition, knowing the manager on duty at the time, it is possible that I would not have been successful had I tried to do so.

A couple of years ago I was operating the last flight of the day out of DFW for PHX.

At the gate next door the last flight out to LAS (757) was preparing to leave as well. One of the FAs for the 757 had been incapacitated and had to call in sick. (Our 75s were minimally staffed with FAs at the time.)

In order to protect the 75 one of my FAs was taken to enable the 75 to operate. (Understandable)

My flight was going to become a reposition ferry flight and I would carry only about five non-revs, including a non-rev flight attendant. Over 100 pax were going to have to be re-accommodated.

Now comes the stupid part. The non-rev flight attendant had an elective procedure scheduled for the following day and had called in sick for her next trip. She had her uniform and gadget bag with her. She called inflight CS, explained her situation and offered to work the flight to PHX. The inflight scheduler told her that because she had called in sick she was ineligible to work our flight. To punish the inflight for calling in sick our flight was cancelled and we flew an empty airplane to PHX.

In fairness of full disclosure I later told this story to the then VP of OPS and he stated that had I been able to reach him that night he would have intervened and fixed the problem. However, management by putting out one fire at a time is never an effective solution so I still count this as a management screw up. It is not the first time I have encountered bad decision making in inflight management.

Your story next.
 
Company makes big internal promotion to get the fleet launched on time (first flights of the day), being pushed hard to get the door closed regardless of what else is going on- too many passengers for seats, maintenance can not on board, product specialist still on board etc etc etc. After busting a$$ to make this happen, taxi-ing out then sitting sitting sitting waiting for numbers.
 
Sometimes things make no sense at all because it's a decision not intended to benifit at the moment. Here in LAS we sent a havf empty 757 to SAn for the longest time, but a full A320 to PHX. People aways wondered why. It was positioning for the SAN-PHX flight that's oversold every morning. I'm not saying that's the "best" way, but there is actually some logic.

As to the situation above, I'm confused. You only need 1 inflight for every (I think) 20 passengers on a Part 91 with NON REV passengers. With 5 passengers you'd only need one inflight. Had it been an extra section with revenue passengers it would be a different story.
 
US flies under part 121, not 91.
 
UW...stick to the ramp...US does fly part 91 when ferrying aircrafts however you are correct US is a 121 gig 99.9% of the time except when ferrying aircrafts.
 
My flight was going to become a reposition ferry flight and I would carry only about five non-revs, including a non-rev flight attendant. Over 100 pax were going to have to be re-accommodated.

This would be Part 91, not Part 121. Were it Part 121 they would have taken the 100 passengers.
 
Getting my arse ripped for taking a 4 minute PR delay on Fleet Launch waiting for a lady in a wheelchair going to CUN........And the flight still arrived in CLT 16 minutes early.
 
This thread is provided for you, the employee, or you the customer, to provide a narrative of any management decision or practice that both inconvenienced passengers and cost the company revenue.

I will go first.

Let me preface this with the fact that I did not find out about the whole chain of events here until it was too late for me to make the phone calls necessary to fix this problem. In addition, knowing the manager on duty at the time, it is possible that I would not have been successful had I tried to do so.

A couple of years ago I was operating the last flight of the day out of DFW for PHX.

At the gate next door the last flight out to LAS (757) was preparing to leave as well. One of the FAs for the 757 had been incapacitated and had to call in sick. (Our 75s were minimally staffed with FAs at the time.)

In order to protect the 75 one of my FAs was taken to enable the 75 to operate. (Understandable)

My flight was going to become a reposition ferry flight and I would carry only about five non-revs, including a non-rev flight attendant. Over 100 pax were going to have to be re-accommodated.

Now comes the stupid part. The non-rev flight attendant had an elective procedure scheduled for the following day and had called in sick for her next trip. She had her uniform and gadget bag with her. She called inflight CS, explained her situation and offered to work the flight to PHX. The inflight scheduler told her that because she had called in sick she was ineligible to work our flight. To punish the inflight for calling in sick our flight was cancelled and we flew an empty airplane to PHX.

In fairness of full disclosure I later told this story to the then VP of OPS and he stated that had I been able to reach him that night he would have intervened and fixed the problem. However, management by putting out one fire at a time is never an effective solution so I still count this as a management screw up. It is not the first time I have encountered bad decision making in inflight management.

Your story next.

I think this decision was a crew scheduler decision is not a member of management. Just not a great decision by a scheduler and this is not to "stand by" management but rather a way to differentiate the two. Schedulers are not considered "management", they are admin and analyst level
 
What on earth is an "inflight"? Can I find in my bag of gadgets? Should it be fed bits of tid?
 
Back
Top